Whether you are meeting up with friends for brunch or enjoying a relaxing day at the seaside, adding a touch of mascara can instantly enhance your look. A compact tube filled with richly pigmented formula can provide unparalleled definition and depth to your eyes. With just a single coat and a skillful application, you can achieve beautifully curled, lengthened, and volumized lashes that capture attention from every angle with the best waterproof mascaras.
Given the high expectations we have for this small beauty essential, it is essential to invest in the finest product available. You need mascara that will not smudge or budge, staying in place for hours on end while delivering luxurious lashes that last for days.
Here are 11 Best Waterproof Mascaras You Need to Try
#1 Dior show Iconic Over curl Waterproof Mascara
This highly-rated mascara received outstanding feedback in our consumer tests. It achieved the highest satisfaction score, with testers praising its ability to create the desired look and its impeccable resistance to smudging. It also scored remarkably well for its curling capability, thanks to its curved wand that effortlessly enhances lashes.
#2 Maybelline New York Great Lash Waterproof Mascara
The performance of this best-selling mascara, housed in its iconic pink tube, thoroughly impressed our experts. During rigorous Lab tests, it showcased exceptional resistance to smudging, solidifying its reputation as a reliable choice. Testers raved about the easy-to-use brush, which facilitated a smooth application without any clumping or flaking throughout the day. One tester specifically mentioned that the mascara effectively held a curl, even on longer lashes that tend to stick straight out.
#3 CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Waterproof Mascara
This beloved cult classic waterproof mascara by Maybelline has gained immense popularity for its affordability, making it accessible to a wide range of users. With its budget-friendly price point, it has attracted a devoted following for its exceptional performance and quality, solidifying its reputation as a top choice in the market. Its smooth application, effortlessly delivering impressive volume.
And length to the lashes without any flaking or smudging issues, enamoured our testers. They particularly lauded the user-friendly brush, finding it exceptionally easy to use. Notably, the formula earned perfect scores for being non-irritating, making it suitable even for individuals with sensitive eyes and skin.
#4 Maybelline New York Volum’ Express the Colossal Waterproof Mascara
A waterproof mascara with an impressive count of over 15,000 five-star reviews on Amazon, it is no wonder that customers are enamoured with this waterproof mascara formula. While we have not had the opportunity to test it in our Beauty Lab, users swear by its long-lasting performance and its ability to resist flaking. Many reviewers have praised the wand, highlighting its excellent job in coating and separating lashes with minimal clumping. Ease of use is another standout feature, with most users finding that just one coat is sufficient, and the mascara stays put throughout the day.
#5 CoverGirl Peacock Flare Waterproof Mascara
Get ready to achieve feathery lashes with the help of this mascara’s unique helix-shaped rubber wand. During our laboratory examinations, this product demonstrated exceptional performance by receiving top scores in terms of resisting smudges, smears, and runs. Testers expressed satisfaction with its non-irritating properties and pleasant scent, making it highly suitable for individuals with sensitive skin and a sensitive sense of smell. Our testers praised the ease of use of the brush applicator. However, testers did note that they needed to apply a few coats to achieve their desired look and expressed a desire for more volume.
#6 Dior show Pump ‘N’ Volume Waterproof Mascara
Dior’s mascara is one of the best waterproof mascaras separating lashes, and creating a stunning, natural look. The thicker formula thrilled testers by providing more definition and enhancement to their lashes. It is essential to highlight that this formula has a higher tendency for flaking and clumping in comparison to alternative options. Despite this drawback, its staying power impressed testers. This product demonstrated remarkable resilience by withstanding a range of challenges, including the application of moisturizing eye drops throughout the day, exposure to onion fumes while cutting, and even emotional moments experienced during Easter Sunday services at churchy.
#7 Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara
If you find the process of removing waterproof mascara cumbersome, consider this water-resistant alternative. While it may not be fully waterproof, its budge-proof formula offers superior longevity against teary eyes and sweaty days compared to traditional non-waterproof mascaras. You will experience the benefits of long-lasting wear without the hassle of dealing with a truly waterproof formula during removal. Beauty editors highly regard this mascara for its ability to lengthen, volumize, and separate lashes, which has garnered it a dedicated fan base.
#8 Maybelline New York Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara
While we have not conducted formal Lab testing on this mascara, it comes highly recommended. Our experts favor this mascara for its smooth application, quick drying time. And its ability to withstand humid days and allergy seasons without compromising the voluminous appearance of lashes. The non-waterproof version of this mascara has also received positive feedback. And earned the status of a top pick in our latest mascara test. With its strong reputation, this mascara is worth considering for achieving a plush lash look that lasts.
#9 Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara
Boasting an impressive count of nearly 103,000 reviews on Amazon, this mascara has garnered a devoted following. While we have not conducted specific testing in our Lab, the overwhelming consensus from five-star reviewers is that this budge-proof formula is a game-changer. Reviewers rave about its long-lasting performance, noting that it stays put all day without flaking. They also highlight how it enhances lash fullness. And emphasize that users can easily remove it with makeup wipes at the end of the day.
#10 Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara
For those who prioritize clean beauty, vegan, and cruelty-free mascara makeup, this “clean” iteration of a cult classic is a perfect choice. In our Lab tests, it achieved a flawless score for its ability to resist running when exposed to water. Consumer testers also raved about its volumizing and thickening effects, resulting in fuller and longer-looking lashes. It garnered high satisfaction ratings and earned praise for its ease of application. Also, enabling a thorough coating of every lash.
#11 Inimitable Waterproof Mascara
Testers were highly impressed with this mascara, particularly its ability to separate. And lengthen lashes, which earned it top scores in those categories. In Lab tests, it came in a close second for volumizing, showcasing its effectiveness in creating high-impact lashes. Testers appreciated the easy-to-use brush, which facilitated smooth and clump-free application, often achieving desired results with just a single coat.